Comprehensive Report Provides Effective Approaches to School Discipline

August 18, 2014

Each year, millions of students are removed from their classrooms for minor misconduct. This puts them at a significantly higher risk of falling behind academically, dropping out of school, and potentially being forced into the juvenile justice system.

Of these students who face school discipline, a disproportionately large percentage are youth of color, students with disabilities, and students who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender.

At the Federation, we are committed to building safe and welcoming schools where students are free from harsh discipline policies. And we know our members are, too.

A new report from the Council of State Governments Justice Center (CSG Justice Center) can help you to better understand the most effective approaches to school discipline in order to influence schools to adopt better policies. The School Discipline Consensus Report provides school leaders, state and local government officials, and advocates with more than 60 recommendations for overhauling ineffective approaches to school discipline.

Download The School Discipline Consensus Report here.

CSG Justice Center has worked with more than 100 key experts, including members from the Dignity in Schools Campaign, over the past three years to identify evidence-based recommendations to reform discipline in public schools. The report includes strategies that are practical, innovative, and based on successful efforts that have been made in schools across the country.

According to the report, improving school discipline policy requires addressing the disparate impact that the current approach has on particular student populations:

  • Black, Hispanic, and American Indian students are suspended at much higher rates than their white peers—sometimes at double the rate.
  • Twenty percent of secondary school students with disabilities were suspended in a single school year, compared to fewer than ten percent of their peers without disabilities.
  • LGBT youth are up to three times more likely to experience harsh disciplinary treatment than their non-LGBT counterparts.

The School Discipline Consensus Report offers recommendations to help decrease the disparities present in school discipline policies. And it establishes what it will take to reduce the number of youth suspended from school while providing learning conditions that help all students succeed.

This report teaches us that the only way to achieve our goal is to work with one another — to create a combination of a positive school climate, tiered levels of behavioral interventions, and a partnership between education, police, and court officials that is dedicated to preventing youth arrests or referrals to the juvenile justice system for minor school-based offenses.

Suspensions, expulsions and police interventions in schools harm students’ chances of success. It is our job as leaders to promote a more supportive school environment.

Download The School Discipline Consensus Report here.

More You might like

Black & LGBTQ+ Organizations Mobilize in High-Stakes Supreme Court Battle

We joined The Center for HIV Law and Policy (CHLP), PrEP in Black America (PIBA), Afiya Center (Dallas), Women with a Vision (New Orleans), SisterLove (Atlanta), and BlaqOut (Kansas City, Missouri) in filing an amicus, or “friend of the court,” brief in the Braidwood v Kennedy case on appeal in the Supreme Court in order to take a stand defending access to preventative health care nationally and to protect the Black and brown lives that will be lost should this access be overturned.

September 6, 2024
Leading Doesn’t Have to Be Lonely

Last month, we hosted our New Executive Director Intensive, one of our longest-running leadership programs. For over a decade, this program has brought together Executive Directors who are new in their role to foster healthy, sustainable organizations and leadership practices. Here are inspiring takeaways we got out of this year’s intensive!

March 7, 2025
Spotlight Interview featuring Ronnie, Advocacy, Policy, & Partnerships Director at FreeState Justice

In recognition of HIV is Not a Crime Day and Maryland's recent groundbreaking progress toward HIV law reform, we sat down for a conversation with Ronnie at FreeState Justice, one of our state partners. We discuss Maryland’s historic progress, its significance in the current landscape of HIV criminalization across the United States, and the importance of Black LGBTQ+ leadership in shaping HIV justice.

September 6, 2024
A young man looking up, smilingA young man smiling straight at the camera
Confident young woman standing with crossed arms.

Want To Make A Difference? Support Our Work

With your support, we'll be able to continue our work to build the leaders of today and tomorrow, strengthen state-based LGBTQ+ organizations, and make critical progress on the issues that matter most—like protecting transgender people, ending HIV criminalization and ensuring access to care, and banning conversion therapy across the country.